The Cambridge Companion to Brentano, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, ____ (), Immanent realism: an introduction to Brentano. The word itself, which is of medieval Scholastic origin, was rehabilitated by the philosopher Franz Brentano towards the end of the nineteenth. Intencionalidad y verdad en el juicio: Una propuesta de Brentano (Publicaciones de la Facultad de Filosofía y Letras de la Universidad de Navarra. Colección.

Author: Vigrel Metaur
Country: Dominica
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Software
Published (Last): 13 November 2004
Pages: 59
PDF File Size: 19.96 Mb
ePub File Size: 7.27 Mb
ISBN: 839-9-38362-382-7
Downloads: 48549
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Shanris

On Tye’s view, for example, pains are mental representations of bodily parts and the phenomenal experience of a pain is the nonconceptual content of the bodily representation. In the case of singular beliefs, the two-tiered account of intentionality is motivated by the considerations reviewed in section 3 that led Frege to distinguish two dimensions of the content of a belief, which he called respectively the sense Sinn or mode of presentation and the reference Bedeutung.

Intencionalifad second criterion amounts to recognition that if a sentence containing a singular term reports an intentional phenomenon, then it fails the test of the substitutivity of coreferential terms salva veritate. Not so with belief, as we shall see momentarily.

This question has given rise to a major division within analytic philosophy. This problem, which has different facets see Kim for a discussion of the several facets of the problem of mental causationturned out to be a difficult problem for Descartes’ ontological dualism.

Aquilina Satue Alvarez, La doctrina de la intencionalidad en Franz Brentano – PhilPapers

Suppose that Ava correctly believes that Hesperus is shining as a result of seeing that Hesperus shines. Edit this record Mark as duplicate Export citation Find it on Scholar Request removal from index Translate to english Revision history.

Other intentional realists deny the supervenience requirement and elaborate a suitable notion of what intentionality is supposed to explain—or what is the proper explanandum of a causal explanation in the explanans of which intentionality might figure prominently.

In between the intentionalists and the phenomenal realists, who accept the dual view, lies the intermediate view of philosophers such as Colin McGinnSydney Shoemaker and Charles Siewertwho see an intimate connection between intentional and phenomenal states. Advocates of the extended mind thesis stress instead the fact that the contribution of non-mental vehicles with content e.


But on Frege’s view, one cannot validly infer 13b from 13a if 13a has no truth-value. But no intentional agent is responsible for the sorting. Some, like Ned Block, would accept a dual view according to which mental states fall into a division between intentional states and phenomenal states.


Thus, the issue between the intentional-object theorist and his critic is whether the variable bound by the standard existential quantifier of first-order logic should range not merely over concrete particulars existing in space and time but also over all sorts of other entities brenyano well.

Brentano y los problemas de intencionalidad

One contentious issue is whether the teleological approach championed by Millikan can be combined with informational semantics so that S can be said to represent instances of property F if and intenckonalidad if it is S ‘s function to carry information about F.

Oxford and New York: Before examining various contradictory answers to these questions, a preliminary question is relevant. In particular, the problem is: For further discussion, see intencionaliddad entry on Bertrand Russell. Galen Strawson – – Teorema: Oxford Handbook to the Philosophy of MindOxford: However, in the absence of detailed knowledge of the physical laws that govern the behavior of a physical system, the intentional idiom is a useful stance for predicting a system’s behavior.

Jntencionalidad – – Teorema: The challenge then is to elaborate a two-tiered account of intentionality according to which one dimension of intentionality does, and the other does not, supervene on the intrinsic properties of an individual’s brain.

Franz Brentano’s Analysis of Truth. Or did he mean both? According to intencionnalidad third thesis, intentionality is the mark of the mental: Still, the point intencionaldad by nomicity is that the intensionality of a linguistic report is not sufficient for the intentionality of the reported phenomenon.

But they are constituents of the contents of the former. Intentionality is the power of minds to be about, to represent, or to stand for, things, properties and states of affairs. The machine delivered e. On the other hand, Ava’s belief is a state internal to Ava.

Intentionality (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Philosophy of LanguageNew York: Sign in to use this feature. Their logical function is that of a definite description. Frege offered a very influential solution to both puzzles. First, many of the insights of the theory of direct reference have been extended from thoughts about concrete individuals to thoughts about natural kinds by Kripke and Putnam How can a person correctly believe that Pegasus does not exist?


We now turn to the tension between content externalism and mental causation. A problem with this strategy is that it is not clear just how narrow content is to be individuated. From within the orthodox paradigm, one central piece of the mystery of intentionality can be brought out by reflection on the conditions in which simple singular thoughts about concrete individuals are true.

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University’s proxy server Configure custom proxy use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy.

The theory of intentional objects, however, may derive support from the following, arguably counterintuitive, consequences of Frege’s and Russell’s views, respectively. Alternatively, an utterance of 10 says of someone who is in fact a Socialist, and who therefore is not Chirac, that he could have been elected president in Given any sort of biological purpose or design, it might fail to be fulfilled.

One is the assumption that the mystery of the intentional relation should be elucidated against the background of non-intentional relations. One may admire not only Albert Einstein but also Sherlock Holmes a fictitious character. For further discussion, see the entry on Gottlob Frege. If one is intencuonalidad directly acquainted with an object, then one must instead form a general thought that is not about any particular individual.

First of all, they have been eager to avoid what they see as the heavy ontological commitments incurred by intentional-object theories. So, for example, the truth of 21 does not entail the truth of 22 even though everything that happens to exemplify property Q happens to exemplify property R: The paradigm of the intentional relation that satisfies orthodox prejudices is the intentionality of what can be intejcionalidad singular thoughts, namely those true thoughts that are directed towards concrete individuals or particulars that exist in space and time.

Many are also about another’s psychological states e.

For further discussion, see the entry on reference. Not many contemporary philosophers of mind would accept Rorty’s irrealist picture of the mind.